Home » Share Market » Understanding Direct Indexing

Understanding Direct Indexing

One technique for efficiently storing and retrieving data in information retrieval systems is direct indexing. Every item in the collection is given an index number for quick and simple access in this simplest type of indexing.

We’ll go into more detail about direct indexing and its several facets in this blog article. We will go over the benefits and drawbacks of direct indexing in addition to its distinctions from other indexing techniques. So, let’s get started: –

What is direct indexing?

Instead of purchasing an exchange-traded fund (ETF) or standard index fund, investors can use direct indexing as an investment strategy to directly own a portfolio of individual stocks or securities that match the performance of a particular index, such as the S&P 500.

By choosing and allocating weight to individual stocks in accordance with their values, tax implications, and financial objectives, investors can tailor their portfolios through direct indexing.

Results from a September 2022 poll by Broadridge Financial Advisors show that just 44% of financial advisors are “proficient” in their knowledge of direct indexing, and only 16% of them now incorporate it into their clients’ portfolios.

Although the initial uptake was rather limited, there is a clear tendency toward increased use. Of the companies who are aware of direct indexing, an astounding 93% have either included it in their offerings already or have specific intentions to do so. Furthermore, a noteworthy 84% of participants from bigger financial institutions have already used a direct indexing solution in the industry.

How does direct indexing work?

When you own equities in a passive index investing directly, you are said to be a direct indexers. Although it’s a really simple concept, very few people actually use it, and those who do typically work with an advisor in an account that is managed independently. One reason is that certain indexes follow less “liquid” segments of the market, where the underlying securities may be thinly traded and priced inefficiently. Direct index funds that track these indexes frequently replicate the performance of an index through sampling or optimization techniques.

However, it is difficult to replicate even the S&P 500, a relatively compact index made up of highly liquid (and easily tradeable) equities. Traditionally, one obstacle to doing this has been that if you don’t have a lot of money to invest, you can’t buy every stock in the index. The primary aim of MF is to enable investors to pool their money with that of another trader in order to purchase hundreds or thousands of securities and form diverse portfolios.

The advent of commission-free trading and fractional-share stock buying, which permits individuals to buy fractional shares in a certain dollar amount, are two factors that have made direct indexing a more appealing alternative for an increasing number of investors in recent years. It is significantly simpler to match the proportions of the index fund direct growth when one can invest fractionally due to the fluctuations in stock prices.

Advantages of direct indexing

  • Fast retrieval: As mentioned earlier, direct indexing allows for quick and efficient retrieval of data as it uses unique index numbers to identify and locate items.
  • Simple implementation: Direct indexing is a straightforward method and can be easily applied in a database or information retrieval system.
  • Efficient use of memory: Since only the index numbers and associated data are stored, direct indexing is memory-efficient compared to other indexing methods, such as inverted indexing.
  • Easy to update: Updating or adding new items in a collection using direct indexing is simple and does not require reorganizing the entire index.

Disadvantages of direct indexing

  • Limited flexibility: Direct indexing can only be used for exact match searches, and it cannot handle partial or fuzzy matches.
  • High overhead cost: The overhead cost increases as the collection grows in size since each item needs to have a unique index number assigned to it.
  • Not ideal for textual data: Direct indexing is not suitable for textual data, as it can be challenging to assign unique index numbers to each word or phrase in a text.
  • Lack of ranking: In direct indexing, the items are retrieved based on their assigned index number and not by relevance or ranking.

How does direct indexing differ from other indexing methods?

There are various types of indexing methods used in information retrieval systems, and each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Here’s how direct indexing differs from some popular indexing methods:

  1. Inverted indexing

In inverted indexing, the data is organized by creating a list of unique terms present in the collection and associating them with their respective documents or entries. This method is mainly used for text-based data and allows for partial or fuzzy matches.

Unlike direct indexing, inverted indexing can handle more complex search queries, but it requires more memory as it stores the entire index along with the data.

  1. Hashing

Hashing is a technique where a hash function is used to convert keys into index numbers. This method is popular in databases and information retrieval systems that perfectly deal with large amounts of data.

Unlike direct indexing, hashing allows for efficient searching and updating of data, but it is more complex to implement and can be resource-intensive.

  1. Binary search trees

Binary search trees are hierarchical structures used for indexing and storing data. They provide efficient searching capabilities by dividing the data into smaller subgroups based on their values.

Compared to direct indexing, binary search trees require more memory and are slower in retrieval as they involve traversing the tree to find the desired item.

The bottom line

Direct indexing is a fundamental method used in information retrieval systems, and it has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. It provides fast and simple access to data but is limited in its flexibility for handling complex search queries. Understanding direct indexing is crucial for anyone working with databases or information retrieval systems.


How is direct indexing different from inverted indexing?

Direct indexing uses unique index numbers to identify and retrieve data, while inverted indexing creates a list of terms and associates them with their respective documents.

How does direct indexing compare to binary search trees?

Direct indexing offers faster retrieval but requires more memory compared to binary search trees, which divide data into smaller subgroups for efficient searching.

How is direct indexing different from inverted indexing?

Direct indexing uses unique index numbers to identify and retrieve data, while inverted indexing creates a list of terms and associates them with their respective documents.

What is the main purpose of direct indexing?

The main purpose of direct indexing is to quickly and efficiently retrieve data by assigning each item in a collection a unique index number.

How does direct indexing help with taxes?

Through the use of technology, advisors can potentially reduce their clients’ tax bills through two key ways with direct indexing: 
(1) tax-managed transitions of concentrated stock positions or existing portfolios.
(2) active, ongoing tax-loss harvesting, both of which lessen the tax burden.

What is the recommended use case for direct indexing?

Direct indexing is best suited for the simple retrieval of data in collections with a limited and known set of items. Overall, direct indexing is a useful method for fast and efficient access to data but may not be suitable for all types of data or search queries.

Enjoyed reading this? Share it with your friends.

Post navigation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *