Scalping vs Swing Trading: Which Strategy Should You Choose?

You might have monitored the markets closely as price moves rapidly to make profits with scalping. But if you were identifying trends and holding positions for several days to capitalise on larger price moves, that’s swing trading. Both strategies are practiced, yet they require different mindsets and risk tolerances. 

Hence, you must know the details of Scalping vs Swing trading and how they help traders. Let’s see which should be chosen and what are their individual benefits.

What is Scalping in Trading?

Traders using scalping can catch small price changes that happen in just seconds or minutes. They jump in and out of the market quickly, often placing trades in a single day. To make these small price moves count, scalpers trade with bigger position sizes. 

What is Swing Trading?

Rather than jumping in and out of trades within minutes, traders doing swing trading hold their positions for several days or weeks. Traders have time to plan their entries and manage their exits. You can use daily or even weekly timelines if you are a swing trader. 

Key Differences Between Scalping and Swing Trading

Feature	Scalping	Swing Trading
Trade Duration	Seconds to minutes	Days to weeks
Trade Frequency	Very high	Low to medium
Profit Target	Small profits per trade	Larger profits per trade
Stop-Loss	Very tight to limit losses quickly	Wider to accommodate price swings
Risk Level	More because of trade frequency and fast moves	Medium as exposed to overnight risks
Time Commitment	Full-time and intense screen time	Part-time or full-time
Analysis	Short-term price action and order flow	Technical or fundamental trend analysis
Stress or Skill	High stress, needs fast thinking	Lower stress, requires patience

Scalping vs Swing Trading: Which is Better for Beginners?

There are two ways to trade. In scalping, you can catch quick moves, get in and out of the trades within a few seconds. In the other, you wait for strong setups and watch it grow. That’s swing trading. The pace, the pressure, and the planning are totally different. 

Pros and Cons of Scalping

See what are the pros and cons of scalping:

Pros

• You don’t wait long to know if a trade worked.
• As trades can be closed after the session ends, you avoid losses from news.
• Stop-loss orders are placed close to entry. 

Cons

• The more you trade, the more you pay in commissions. 
• Scalping demands your full attention.
• It takes time, skill, and tools. 

Pros and Cons of Swing Trading

Check out the pros and cons of swing trading:

Pros

• You can check charts once or twice.
• Since trades are held for days or weeks, there’s a better chance to catch big moves.
• Fewer trades mean fewer charges from brokers.

Cons 

• You won’t see profits right away.
• You could sell a stock for a small profit.
• You’ll need to learn patterns, trends, and price action.

Scalping vs Swing Trading: Which is More Profitable?

If you’re quick-thinking and want short bursts of action, scalping may suit you. But if you prefer a calmer pace, swing trading may give better results. Most traders find swing trading more doable long term.

Risk Management for Scalping and Swing Trading

Scalping vs Swing trading both demand strict risk management, but in different ways. Scalpers go for tight stop-losses, fast exits, and smaller trade sizes. However, swing traders plan entries and exits in advance and use a higher reward-to-risk ratio. 

Best Markets for Scalping vs Swing Trading

Markets for scalping:

• Forex
• Futures
• Crypto
• Large-cap Stocks

Markets for swing trading: 

• Stocks
• ETFs and Indices
• Forex
• Commodities and Select Cryptos

Tools and Indicators for Scalping vs Swing Trading

The best tools and indicators for scalping vs swing trading are listed below:

Key Tools and Indicators for Scalping:

• Central Pivot Range (CPR): Helps spot daily turning points.
• VWAP: Used to see the average price weighted by volume.
• Short-Term Moving Averages (EMA/SMA): Shows if prices are trending up or down over very short periods.
• RSI (7 or 9 period): Spots quick overbought or oversold moves.
• Parabolic SAR: Sets quick stop-and-reverse points for fast trades.

Key Tools and Indicators for Swing Trading:

• Moving Averages: Crossovers like the 50-day over the 200-day signal possible entry points.
• RSI: Check for the points where the market might show reversal after being overbought or oversold.
• Bollinger Bands: Shows breakout areas for multi-day moves.
• Volume Indicators: Validates if a trend is backed by sustained participation.
• Fibonacci Retracement: Marks reversal areas.

Tips for Choosing Between Scalping and Swing Trading

Let’s see how to figure out if you’re better at Scalping vs Swing trading. 

1. Check How Much Time You Can Give

In scalping, you need to watch every candle every second. However, swing trading requires checking charts once in the morning and in the evening. 

2. Handle Stress

If you enjoy quick results and can close multiple trades in one hour, you might go for scalping. In swing trading, you might see your trade dip in losses before it goes bullish.

3. Look at How You Manage Risk

Scalpers avoid gap-ups or crashes when the market opens the next day. Swing traders go for wider stop-loss options and accept if there is any short-term dip before the bigger move.

4. Look for the Brokerage Fees

If you scalp, trading fees can take up your profits quickly. Swing trading doesn’t take much broker fees, so you can focus on charts that show longer trends and volume patterns. 

5. Prepare a Strategy 

If you like the quick wins, scalping may fit. You’ll chase small profits but collect them often. If you want to set up a trade, you should go for swing trading. You wait longer for your payoff, but it can be bigger per trade.

Conclusion 

Scalping is for traders who take fast action and are ready to sit through intense market moves for frequent gains. Swing trading is preferred by traders who can spot trends and hold trades for days to capture bigger price shifts. You must choose as per your patience, risk you can handle, and time you can give for tracking trades.

FAQs