
- Summary
- The key difference between MCX and NCDEX is their product focus. MCX mainly trades bullion, industrial metals and energy derivatives, while NCDEX mainly focuses on agricultural commodity derivatives.
- MCX generally has much higher overall trading activity, particularly in contracts such as gold, silver and crude oil, although liquidity still varies by individual contract.
- NCDEX focuses on agricultural products such as guar seed, guar gum, turmeric, castor seed and cottonseed oil cake, subject to current contract availability.
- The better exchange depends on the commodity, contract liquidity, trading hours, costs and your understanding of the relevant derivatives market.
Commodity trading in India is conducted via the recognised exchanges which offer standardised contracts for the trading of commodity derivatives. The two major exchanges in this space are the Multi Commodity Exchange of India (MCX) and the National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange (NCDEX). While both of these exchanges provide the facility for trading in commodity derivatives, they do so in very different ways. The nature of the products traded, the level of trading activity, the contract specifications and the market hours are all different. Knowing the differences between MCX and NCDEX will enable a trader to compare the available contracts and determine which exchange is of relevance to their trading.
MCX vs NCDEX at a Glance
| Basis of comparison | MCX | NCDEX |
| Full name | Multi Commodity Exchange of India Limited | National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange Limited |
| Main focus | Bullion, metals and energy commodities | Agricultural commodities |
| Examples of commodities | Gold, silver, crude oil, natural gas and copper | Guar seed, guar gum, turmeric, castor seed and cottonseed oil cake |
| Trading activity | Generally higher across the commodity derivatives market | More concentrated in agricultural commodity contracts |
| Trading hours | Generally 9:00 AM to 11:30 PM or 11:55 PM for internationally referenced non-agricultural commodities, depending on the US daylight-saving season | Normal trading session generally runs from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM |
| Contract specifications | Contract sizes and specifications vary by commodity and contract | Contract sizes and specifications vary by agricultural commodity and contract |
| Key price drivers | International prices, currency movements, industrial demand and geopolitical developments | Crop production, weather, domestic supply and demand, government policies and export conditions |
| Settlement | Depends on the contract specifications and settlement rules | Depends on the contract specifications and settlement rules |
| Best suited to | Traders interested in liquid bullion, metals and energy contracts | Traders interested in agricultural commodity derivatives |
Trading volume comparison
For FY 2025-26 MCX had an average daily turnover of around ₹5.4 lakh crore. NCDEX’s futures turnover and options notional turnover for the same year came in at approximately ₹1.74 lakh crore. That works out to an indicative average of around ₹703 crore per day (based on 248 trading days). These are the figures for futures and options notional turnover and not the number of contracts traded or the options premium turnover.
Data as at 31st March 2026 for FY 2025-26. MCX figure: exchange reported average daily turnover. NCDEX figure: calculated from the FY 2025-26 exchange turnover figures as reported in SEBI’s annual report. Figures are rounded.
What is MCX?
The Multi Commodity Exchange of India Limited (MCX) is a recognised commodity derivatives exchange which commenced operations in November 2003. It provides an electronic platform for trading in commodity futures and options and is thus a key enabler for market participants to manage price risk and discover prices.
MCX is predominantly a bullion, industrial metals and energy products exchange. The range of products available via its contracts includes gold, silver, crude oil, natural gas, copper and aluminium (subject to the current product list of the exchange).
The exchange also offers contracts on commodity indices. Trading activity is obviously affected by international commodity prices, currency movements, global demand and supply and geopolitical events. Prices can be very volatile as a result and traders need to be clear on the contract specs and the risks involved prior to taking any position.
What is NCDEX?
The National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange Limited (NCDEX) is a recognised commodity derivatives exchange which started up in December 2003. It is an agricultural commodities exchange and provides a platform for trading of standardised derivatives contracts.
Its commodity lines are guar seed and guar gum, spices, oilseeds, pulses and a range of other agricultural products. The markets are all subject to the influence of crop output, rainfall, storage, domestic demand, export and government policy.
NCDEX is relevant to participants who want to trade agricultural derivatives or manage price exposure related to agricultural produce. Contract availability can change, so traders should check the exchange’s current list before choosing a commodity. Understanding how NCDEX compares with MCX can help clarify the differences in their commodity offerings.
What Each Exchange Actually Trades
MCX and NCDEX have different product mixes, although the exact contracts available can change over time.
MCX commodities
- Bullion: Gold and silver.
- Industrial metals: Aluminium, copper, lead, nickel, steel rebar and zinc.
- Energy: Crude oil, natural gas and electricity.
- Agricultural commodities: Cardamom, cotton, cotton seed wash oil, kapas and mentha oil, subject to current contract availability.
These products can be impacted by international benchmark prices, currency movements, industrial activity, energy demand and global supply issues. A shift in international crude oil prices would for instance have an impact on crude oil contracts on MCX.
NCDEX commodities
- Guar complex: Guar seed and guar gum.
- Spices: Turmeric, dhaniya and jeera.
- Oilseed and related products: Castor seed and cottonseed oil cake.
- Other commodities: NCDEX also lists Steel Long, so its product mix is primarily, rather than exclusively, agricultural.
Agricultural contracts can be responsive to monsoon conditions, crop estimates, the harvest cycle, storage availability, export restrictions and changes in domestic consumption. A bad harvest for example would impact the supply outlook which would be reflected in the price of the agricultural commodity.
The key point is that you pick the product and contract you’re after, rather than thinking that every product is available on both exchanges.
Difference between MCX and NCDEX
1. Commodity offerings
MCX is of course the bullion, metals and energy exchange, NCDEX is the agricultural exchange. That’s the most obvious difference between the two.
The point is that the determinants of price are different. Gold and oil will be very much influenced by international events and by the state of the currency, whereas the agriculturals will be more influenced by weather, crop yields and domestic policy.
2. Trading volume and liquidity
MCX generally sees a lot higher turnover across the commodity derivatives market. The bullion and energy contracts in particular attract a broad range of participants (traders, businesses, institutions etc).
NCDEX has lower overall turnover but does serve a more specialised agricultural derivatives market. Liquidity varies enormously from contract to contract on either exchange. A contract that is heavily traded will have much narrower bid-ask spreads and hence will be easier to get into and out of, whereas a contract that is less actively traded will be more costly to enter or exit.
Overall exchange turnover is of some use for comparison but traders should always look at the liquidity of the individual contract they’re looking at.
3. Trading hours
MCX has extended the trading hours for a number of internationally referenced commodities so that market participants can react to the global market. NCDEX’s normal session is of course considerably shorter.
The close varies by commodity. At MCX internationally referenced non-agri commodities trade until 11.30pm during the US daylight saving period and until 11.55pm after the US daylight saving period ends. Internationally referenced agri commodities trade until 9.00pm and other agri commodities until 5.00pm.
NCDEX’s normal trading session is 10.00 am to 5.00 pm, Mon-Fri for the majority of the commodities. The Mumbai Rainfall contract has its own trading hours. Sessions can be altered via exchange circular so traders are advised to check the most current NCDEX trading hours notice prior to placing any orders.
4. Contract specifications and lot sizes
Both exchanges offer standardised contracts, each commodity having its own contract unit, quotation method, expiry and settlement. Different grades of the same commodity can also have different lot sizes.
Lot size has an impact on the value of the position and the amount of money you’ll need to trade it. A larger contract may be subject to a greater price movement in rupee terms. You therefore need to look at the contract specifications, tick size, expiry and margin required rather than just the quoted price of the commodity.
5. Price movements and market influences
MCX prices are frequently driven by international commodity benchmarks, currency movements, geopolitical developments and industrial demand. Gold and silver can be sensitive to global financial instability, while crude oil is likely to be affected by supply decisions and geopolitical events.
NCDEX prices are more closely tied to agricultural conditions (monsoon, crop production, inventory, export demand and government policy) and so the timing and magnitude of price movements will reflect those.
Neither of the exchanges is automatically any less risky. Price volatility will be a function of the particular commodity, the contract and the market conditions.
6. Settlement and delivery
Settlement is governed by the contract and the exchange rules. Some contracts will be settled financially, others will be settled by delivery under the relevant rules.
Traders who don’t intend to take delivery need to be aware of the contract’s expiry and the requirement to square off. If you’re going to leave a position open right up to expiry you need to be absolutely clear as to what the settlement is going to be. You could end up with an obligation or a cost that you didn’t anticipate.
Charges and Costs on Each Exchange
The MCX NCDEX charge that a trader pays will vary depending on the broker, the contract and the transaction. There is no one brokerage rate that applies to all trading accounts.
The main costs to check include:
- Brokerage: the fee the broker charges for executing the trade. This may be a flat fee per order or it may be calculated according to the broker’s pricing structure.
- Exchange transaction charges: charges applied to transactions carried out on the exchange. The rate will vary by exchange and contract.
- Commodities Transaction Tax (CTT): CTT applies to specified taxable commodity transactions and generally does not apply to agricultural commodity derivatives. For taxable transactions, the seller pays 0.01% on the sale of a commodity derivative and 0.05% on the sale of an option on a commodity derivative. Separate rates apply when options are exercised.
- GST and other statutory charges: GST and other applicable taxes and levies will be added to the brokerage and other eligible charges.
- Margin requirements (initial margin and any further margin) will vary according to the contract, market conditions and the applicable risk management rules. Margin is not a transaction fee and it is the amount of capital which must be available to support a position.
- Lot size economics: the contract lot size and the price quotation will have an effect on your total exposure and your potential profit or loss from a price movement.
For a fair comparison you’d need to work out the estimated total cost of opening and closing the same type of position on the relevant contract. Check the most up to date broker tariff and exchange charges rather than just assume that one exchange is going to be the cheapest.
Which Exchange Is Right for You?
The decision between MCX and NCDEX comes down to the commodity you’re trading, your own understanding of the price drivers for that commodity and the liquidity of the contract.
MCX may suit you if:
- You want to trade bullion, industrial metals or energy.
- You track international commodity prices and the associated market news.
- The contract you’re looking at has enough trading to support your approach.
- You know the contract’s lot size, margin, expiry and settlement.
NCDEX may suit you if:
- You’re after agricultural commodity derivatives.
- You’re aware of the factors involved i.e. crop production, monsoon, inventories and export demand.
- The agricultural contract has enough liquidity for your trade size.
- You’ve checked the contract specs and the settlement rules.
For beginners: Start by understanding one commodity and its contract rather than choosing an exchange based only on its total turnover. Review the bid-ask spread, trading volume, margin requirements, and potential losses from price movements. Commodity derivatives can involve substantial losses, particularly when leverage is used. Neither exchange guarantees profits, and higher liquidity does not remove market risk.
How to Start Trading on MCX or NCDEX
To trade commodity derivatives on either exchange you’ll generally need an account with a broker that has access to that particular commodity segment.
- Choose a registered broker: Check whether the broker provides access to MCX, NCDEX or both, and review its brokerage and other charges.
- Complete the account-opening process: Submit the required identity, address, PAN and bank details. The broker may also require additional information or documents under its onboarding procedures.
- Complete the required verification: Finish the broker’s KYC process and any required declarations before placing orders.
- Understand the commodity market: Learn how futures and options work, how prices move and what settlement can involve. Understanding the commodity market helps explain the basic concepts behind trading on MCX and NCDEX.
- Review the contract details: Check the lot size, expiry date, quotation unit, tick size, margin requirement and delivery conditions for the selected contract.
- Check costs and risk: Review brokerage, exchange charges, CTT and applicable taxes. Understand the potential loss if the market moves against your position.
- Place orders carefully: Use the broker’s trading platform to select the correct exchange and contract. Monitor open positions and keep track of expiry and margin requirements.
Account access does not mean every contract is suitable for every trader. Beginners should learn the mechanics and risks before committing money to a leveraged position.
Similarities between MCX and NCDEX
Although their main commodity categories differ, MCX and NCDEX share several features:
- Regulation: Both operate within India’s commodity derivatives regulatory framework under the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
- Electronic trading: Both provide electronic platforms for trading listed commodity derivatives.
- Standardised contracts: Each exchange specifies contract terms, including trading units, expiry and settlement conditions.
- Risk management: Both apply exchange-level risk-management and margin requirements.
- Price discovery: Trading activity helps market participants assess prices and manage exposure to commodity price changes.
- Hedging and trading: Their contracts can be used by eligible market participants for hedging or trading, subject to applicable rules.
The fact that the fundamental principles of commodity derivatives trading are the same on both exchanges means that the basic rules of the game are the same. The products, the liquidity and the contract rules however will need to be looked at on a case by case basis.
MCX vs NCDEX: Which Exchange Should You Choose?
MCX and NCDEX cater to very different segments of the Indian commodity derivatives market. MCX is the market for bullion, metals and energy, NCDEX is the market for agricultural commodities. MCX has by far the highest overall turnover but the most pertinent comparison is the liquidity and cost of the individual contract you’re looking at.
Before you make your choice you should compare the available commodity contracts, the trading hours, the lot sizes, the margin requirements, the brokerage and the settlement terms. You should also consider whether or not you understand the factors that affect the price of the commodity. The exchange in itself will not dictate the outcome of the trade. A good choice is one that is appropriate to your level of market knowledge, your risk profile and your trading objectives.
FAQs
MCX has much higher overall turnover simply because its bullion, metals and energy contracts are so much more actively traded. Those markets are driven by international prices, industrial demand and the wider global scene. NCDEX is predominantly an agricultural derivatives exchange and caters to a very different market. For FY 2025-26 MCX’s average daily turnover was approximately ₹5.4 lakh crore whereas NCDEX’s futures and options notional turnover is indicative of around ₹703 crore per day. These are turnover numbers, not number of contracts traded.
Yes, you may be able to trade on both MCX and NCDEX through the same broker account if the broker provides access to both commodity segments and has enabled the relevant trading permissions. You may need to complete additional declarations or verification. Check the broker’s available exchanges, charges and account requirements before placing a trade.
Neither exchange is automatically better for every beginner. MCX may be relevant if you want to learn about bullion, metals or energy contracts, while NCDEX may be relevant if you are interested in agricultural commodities. Start by understanding one commodity, its price drivers, liquidity, lot size and margin requirements. Commodity derivatives can involve substantial losses, so learn the risks before trading.
MCX generally opens at 9:00 AM on weekdays. Internationally referenced non-agricultural commodities generally close at 11:30 PM during the US daylight-saving period and 11:55 PM after it ends. Other agricultural categories may close earlier. NCDEX’s normal trading session generally runs from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM, Monday to Friday. Trading hours can change through exchange notices or special sessions, so check the latest timings before trading.
