Tata Motors PV grows 34%, but cash flow turns negative
TMPV Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Limited (TMPV) reported 34% year on year revenue growth in Q2 FY27 to ₹96,920 crore. Yet it reported a consolidated net loss of approximately ₹5,500 crore. The headline loss needs context. The company recorded ₹6,700 crore in exceptional charges, mainly ₹3,800 crore for employee separation costs and ₹2,900 crore for asset impairments. Before these exceptional items, profit before tax was ₹403 crore. But I would not dismiss the quarter as a one time accounting issue. Consolidated free cash flow was negative ₹6,300 crore for Q2. Net debt reached ₹50,800 crore at September 30. JLR is another concern. Its revenue grew 20.3% year on year, but its adjusted EBIT margin was only 1.1%. Adverse market mix and commodity costs weighed on profitability. The domestic passenger vehicle business also had a mixed quarter. Revenue grew 50.9%, but its EBITDA margin declined by 180 basis points to 4%. There is a clear difference between revenue growth and financial recovery. The year on year improvement partly reflects recovery from last year's JLR cyber incident. Sequentially, margins remain under pressure. My view: The domestic business has momentum, but JLR's margin recovery and group cash generation remain the bigger questions. My stance: I would watch JLR margins, free cash flow and net debt before becoming more constructive. Revenue growth alone is not enough. Disclosure: I do not hold this stock.



















